PLEASE NOTE: emailing susan_mcclintic@ilnd.uscourts.gov is the most efficient way to contact Judge Shah's chambers. Any questions about Judge Shah's practices or cases should be directed to susan_mcclintic@ilnd.uscourts.gov.
Judge Shah hears motions on Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday; Civil Case motions are heard at 9:45 a.m., Criminal Case motions are heard at 10:15 a.m. All motions must be noticed for presentment no later than three business days before the hearing.
Parties should expect to appear in person unless the court advises otherwise. Any request to appear by telephone must be made to susan_mcclintic@ilnd.uscourts.gov no later than 24 hours prior to the motion hearing.
Motions that are agreed or unopposed must include “agreed” or “unopposed” in the title of the motion.
The information on this and linked pages contains important information about my pretrial case management procedures. Please take the time to read it carefully.
These policies and rules have been designed to facilitate the prompt, efficient and equitable disposition of civil cases on my docket. The success of this court's trial procedures depends on your willingness to familiarize yourself with these materials and to act accordingly. Counsel will be expected to fully explain to the court any failure to comply with the court's pretrial procedures.
The parties should use the Seventh Circuit’s Pattern Jury Instructions when
possible, bearing in mind that statutory and binding case law govern over the
pattern instructions. See the Final Pretrial Orders section for the
requirements that parties must follow in drafting and presenting proposed jury
instructions.
Pattern Civil Jury Instructions
The parties should use the Seventh Circuit’s Pattern Jury Instructions when
possible, bearing in mind that statutory and binding case law govern over the
pattern instructions. See the Final Pretrial Orders section for the
requirements that parties must follow in drafting and presenting proposed jury
instructions.
Pattern Civil Jury Instructions
On the morning of jury selection, the parties will be given a copy of the list of potential jurors that is generated by the Clerk’s Office in random order. The entire venire will then enter the courtroom in that order, with the first fourteen jurors seated in the jury box, and the remaining prospective jurors seated in the gallery. The venire will be sworn after some introductory remarks by the judge. The prospective jurors in the jury box will then answer the questions contained in the juror questionnaire and any additional questions governing the case. Questioning will be conducted by the judge. Jurors will be given the opportunity to answer sensitive questions at sidebar if they wish. Once all questions have been asked of the first fourteen jurors, the judge will consult with the parties at sidebar as to additional follow-up questions, and will complete questioning of that group. Challenges for cause will be heard at sidebar.
The remaining jurors, after the first fourteen, will be questioned in the same manner. After the entire venire has been questioned and all challenges for cause have been resolved, the parties will submit peremptory challenges in writing simultaneously. Each side will have three peremptory challenges, and multiple defendants or plaintiffs will be considered a single side for purposes of making challenges. If the parties challenge the same juror, both sides will be charged for that challenge. Once peremptory challenges have been submitted, the challenged prospective jurors will be excused. The jury will consist of eight jurors. There are no alternate jurors. All jurors seated will be allowed to deliberate.
On the morning of jury selection, the parties will be given a copy of the list of potential jurors that is generated by the Clerk’s Office in random order. The entire venire will then enter the courtroom in that order, with the first fourteen jurors seated in the jury box, and the remaining prospective jurors seated in the gallery. The venire will be sworn after some introductory remarks by the judge. The prospective jurors in the jury box will then answer the questions contained in the juror questionnaire and any additional questions governing the case. Questioning will be conducted by the judge. Jurors will be given the opportunity to answer sensitive questions at sidebar if they wish. Once all questions have been asked of the first fourteen jurors, the judge will consult with the parties at sidebar as to additional follow-up questions, and will complete questioning of that group. Challenges for cause will be heard at sidebar.
The remaining jurors, after the first fourteen, will be questioned in the same manner. After the entire venire has been questioned and all challenges for cause have been resolved, the parties will submit peremptory challenges in writing simultaneously. Each side will have three peremptory challenges, and multiple defendants or plaintiffs will be considered a single side for purposes of making challenges. If the parties challenge the same juror, both sides will be charged for that challenge. Once peremptory challenges have been submitted, the challenged prospective jurors will be excused. The jury will consist of eight jurors. There are no alternate jurors. All jurors seated will be allowed to deliberate.
If you are a pro se litigant with a case in this district, the District Court Self-Help Assistance Program may be able to provide you with assistance regarding your case. The help desk attorney operates by appointment only. Appointments are made at the Clerk’s Office Intake Desk on the 20th floor or by calling 312-435-5691.
Use of the help desk attorney is not a substitute for an attorney. You should seriously consider trying to obtain professional legal assistance. Below are lists of organizations that may be able to offer you free or low-cost legal assistance or a referral to an attorney if you can afford to pay for legal services.
Additional Resources/Information:
Free or low-cost legal services
Referral Services
Filing a Civil Case Without An Attorney: A Guide For The Pro Se Litigant
Title VII and Section 1981: A Guide for Appointed Attorneys in the Northern District of Illinois
The Americans With Disabilities Act An Age Discrimination In Employment Act: A Guide for Appointed Attorneys in the Northern District of Illinois
Local Rule 56.2 - Notice to Pro Se Litigants Opposing Summary Judgment
If you are a pro se litigant with a case in this district, the District Court Self-Help Assistance Program may be able to provide you with assistance regarding your case. The help desk attorney operates by appointment only. Appointments are made at the Clerk’s Office Intake Desk on the 20th floor or by calling 312-435-5691.
Use of the help desk attorney is not a substitute for an attorney. You should seriously consider trying to obtain professional legal assistance. Below are lists of organizations that may be able to offer you free or low-cost legal assistance or a referral to an attorney if you can afford to pay for legal services.
Additional Resources/Information:
Free or low-cost legal services
Referral Services
Filing a Civil Case Without An Attorney: A Guide For The Pro Se Litigant
Title VII and Section 1981: A Guide for Appointed Attorneys in the Northern District of Illinois
The Americans With Disabilities Act An Age Discrimination In Employment Act: A Guide for Appointed Attorneys in the Northern District of Illinois
Local Rule 56.2 - Notice to Pro Se Litigants Opposing Summary Judgment
Motions for summary judgment, responses, and replies must comply with Local Rule 56.1 (as amended in February 2021), as well as this standing order. All statements of undisputed material facts and their responses must be filed separately from the memoranda of law and must include the line, paragraph, or page number where the supporting material may be found in the record. See LR 56.1(d)(2), (e)(3).
The Local Rules are not mere technicalities. Failure to comply with the Local Rules may result in the Court striking briefs, disregarding statements of fact, deeming statements of fact admitted, and denying summary judgment. See LR 56.1(a)(3).
Motions to strike are disfavored. See LR 56.1(e)(2). Only on rare occasions is a motion to strike appropriate, such as when an entire brief or 56.1 statement is defective. When it is appropriate, the motion must be made promptly after the filing of the purportedly offending brief or statement. If a party contends that its opponent has included inadmissible evidence, improper argument, or other objectionable material in a LR 56.1 statement, the party should raise its objection in its response or reply brief, not in a motion to strike. See LR 56.1(e)(2), (g).
In complex cases, the Court might request that the parties submit a supplemental chart or organizational aid to summarize the material facts.
Parties should keep the following points in mind:
If you are representing yourself, please refer to Local Rule 56.2 - Notice to Pro Se Litigants Opposing Summary Judgment.
Motions for summary judgment, responses, and replies must comply with Local Rule 56.1 (as amended in February 2021), as well as this standing order. All statements of undisputed material facts and their responses must be filed separately from the memoranda of law and must include the line, paragraph, or page number where the supporting material may be found in the record. See LR 56.1(d)(2), (e)(3).
The Local Rules are not mere technicalities. Failure to comply with the Local Rules may result in the Court striking briefs, disregarding statements of fact, deeming statements of fact admitted, and denying summary judgment. See LR 56.1(a)(3).
Motions to strike are disfavored. See LR 56.1(e)(2). Only on rare occasions is a motion to strike appropriate, such as when an entire brief or 56.1 statement is defective. When it is appropriate, the motion must be made promptly after the filing of the purportedly offending brief or statement. If a party contends that its opponent has included inadmissible evidence, improper argument, or other objectionable material in a LR 56.1 statement, the party should raise its objection in its response or reply brief, not in a motion to strike. See LR 56.1(e)(2), (g).
In complex cases, the Court might request that the parties submit a supplemental chart or organizational aid to summarize the material facts.
Parties should keep the following points in mind:
If you are representing yourself, please refer to Local Rule 56.2 - Notice to Pro Se Litigants Opposing Summary Judgment.
Search warrants or seizure warrants related to a case assigned to Judge Shah should be submitted to the duty magistrate judge. LCrR 41(a).
Search warrants or seizure warrants related to a case assigned to Judge Shah should be submitted to the duty magistrate judge. LCrR 41(a).
Motion Type | Day | Time |
---|---|---|
Civil | T,W,Th | 9:45 a.m. |
Criminal | T,W,Th | 10:15 a.m. |